Prior to the start of the 2018-19 season it seemed the fate of Oiler’s coaching and management was set – at least if you believed the venom of fans and bloggers on social media and radio.
McLellan was given a reprieve with a new stable coaching support, but as for Peter Chiarelli, there was no relief. The Oiler’s had spent to the cap due to questionable FA signings, seemingly lopsided trades, and poor player management. All these combined to put Chia in an exclusive section of Oiler hades (Where Peter Pocklington resides).
With little to work with, it appeared the pre-season PTO’s and signings would be superficial not impactful. if anything, the Oiler’s GM had dug his team in deeper . . . or did he?
Doing a lot with not a lot
The completion of the 2017 – 18 season, left many holes in the Oiler’s line up. Gaps on the wing, veteran leadership, and of course, defence. The need on Defense ultimately remains a festering sore, but overall there have been some pleasant surprises from Chia’s off-season tinkering. Here’s my review so far.
Mikko Koskinen (rating, B+): The Oiler fan base exhaled a collective sigh of disbelief when Chia chose to go out on a limb and sign the 30 year-old KHL all-star. Things looked even dodgier when Koskinen was lit up in the pre-season, but since then his record and play has steadily improved to where he is providing positive competition for Cam Talbot. It’s early days, but in 4 games he has 3 of the Oiler’s 8 wins including a shutout. If he continues to improve it will give the Oilers real options in goal and justify his salary.
Alex Chaisson (rating, A): Prior to the season start there were a lot of unknown’s around Chiasson’s signing. Injured at the beginning of the season there were some questions as to why he was there. But since hitting the ice, Chiasson is letting his play do the talking. With 6 goals in 10 games, he’s doing everything Milan Lucic should be doing at a fraction of the cost. He’ll pay the price by going to the hard areas of the ice and he’s been rewarded – both in production and in the coaching staff’s confidence. Chiasson does have consistency issues, but If he scores even 15 goals he’ll provide excellent value and a stop-gap for when the prospects can catch up.
Tobias Rieder (rating: B): Rieder has no goals in 16 games but he does have 7 apples and with his speed provides the speed component when teamed with countryman Leon Draisaitl. He seems to have good chemistry with LD and on a team where there is a lack of pure speed (save Captain Connor). Overall he seems to be providing what was expected.
Kyle Brodziak ( rating -B): It’s my belief that when the Oilers traded Matt Hendricks it left a large “lead by example” gap in the dressing room. Brodziak does not embody the same level of leadership, but he is a veteran professional who brings a strong work ethic to the rink every day. He’s a good example to the young players and has the skill to make timely contributions from the fourth line. Typically you can’t expect too much from a fourth-line add, but so far so good.
Jason Garrison (D to C-): Garrison was never a fast player, and now he’s even slower. As a result, he is often a defensive liability but, when he is playing well positionally he can survive and, more importantly, he provides a cannon on the 2nd powerplay unit. It may not be enough to keep him in the lineup, but when he is, he will fire away at will. It’s good to see because there are far too many passes on the Oilers power play in my opinion. The good news is, he is not costing the Oilers a lot and can fill a role.
Help on the way?
For the first time in recent memory the Oilers have a farm and prospect system that appears to be in a position to support the big club. On the Bakersfield Condors farm team the kid line of Marody, Hebig, and Benson are producing at a ppg or better. Chiarelli did not physically scout all these players but Cameron Hebig was a very shrewd signing that is paying nice dividends so far.
It’s difficult to project prospects but Marody has already shown well on a brief call-up, at least one of these forwards could be with the big club next year, maybe more. Add standout prospects like Ryan Mcleod and Kirill Maksimov ( non-first rounders ) and you have to say the Oilers have the looks of a legitimate farm system for the first time in . . . well, I can’t recall when the Oilers have had a well-stocked system, to be honest.
What’s a fair assessment of Chiarelli’s Work
To be fair, Chiarelli has more than earned much of his criticism. The Griffin Reinhart trade could go down as one of the worst in NHL history. Many would give the Taylor Hall trade a similar critique, although the question would also need to be asked, what would the Oiler’s Blueline look like without Adam Larsson? Personally, I would have liked to have seen more in return for Larsson, but in my view, it’s clear: Tylor Hall would not have reached his potential here, and may have negatively impacted Mcdavid’s. Lucic? Well, we all liked the signing at the time, now, not so much. For the Oiler’s, bold moves, are not likely. Instead, strategic value signings, good drafting, and a well-stocked prospect system, and farm are how the Oilers will move forward. And on those points, Chia is doing ok.
